Compare skills
Pick 2–4 skills and compare what really matters: fit, risk, install effort, and community signal.
Comparison matrix
Highlights show current best; tooltip explains diff/best rules.
SAS-v2.1 diff rules / risk tag notes
Start with the matrix. Open this section when you need to understand audit grades, top threats, control gaps, and best-value highlights.
TidGi-Desktop
tiddly-gittly/TidGi-Desktop · Score 81
Search to add skills, or paste 2–4 comma-separated slugs.
How differences are detected
A row is marked different when selected skills have distinct values. Only-differences mode hides rows that are identical.
How best values are highlighted
Audit score, evidence confidence, trust score, and community signal prefer higher values; execution risk and install friction prefer lower values.
How to read risk tags
Risk tags come from SAS-v2.1 public-evidence signals and point to command, network, secret, context, or supply-chain items to review before install.
Selected audit signals
qdrant-loader
Execution risk：High
Threat tags：unexpected code execution, data exfiltration, memory context poisoning
Control gaps：missing license, broad permissions, shell without guardrails
scholar-rag
Execution risk：High
Threat tags：unexpected code execution, data exfiltration, memory context poisoning
Control gaps：missing license, broad permissions, shell without guardrails
memory-journal-mcp
Execution risk：High
Threat tags：prompt injection, tool poisoning, unexpected code execution
Control gaps：missing license, broad permissions, shell without guardrails
TidGi-Desktop
Execution risk：High
Threat tags：unexpected code execution, data exfiltration, memory context poisoning
Control gaps：missing license, broad permissions, shell without guardrails
| Dimension | qdrant-loader | scholar-rag | memory-journal-mcp | TidGi-Desktop |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SAS-v2.1 pre-install audit | ||||
Audit grade | C · Review first | C · Review first | D · Limited evidence | C · Review first |
Threat tags | unexpected code execution, data exfiltration, memory context poisoning | unexpected code execution, data exfiltration, memory context poisoning | prompt injection, tool poisoning, unexpected code execution | unexpected code execution, data exfiltration, memory context poisoning |
Permission summary | Permission review, Network, Command | Permission review, Network, Command | Permission review, Network, Secrets, Command | Permission review, Network, Command |
Evidence confidence | 67% | 67% | 71% | 67% |
| Source & provenance | ||||
Provenance | martin-papy/qdrant-loader | PangHu1020/scholar-rag | neverinfamous/memory-journal-mcp | tiddly-gittly/TidGi-Desktop |
Freshness | 2026-04-06 | 2026-04-06 | 2026-04-06 | 2026-04-07 |
| Risk & trust | ||||
Trust score | 81 | 82 | 81 | 81 |
Audit signals | writes files | No explicit signals | ||
| Install & compatibility | ||||
Install friction | 40 | 40 | 55 | 40 |
| Community | ||||
Stars | 37 | 22 | 13 | 2K |
network access |
